'For the person or persons that hold dominion, can no more combine with the keeping up of majesty the running with harlots drunk or naked about the streets, or the performances of a stage player, or the open violation or contempt of laws passed by themselves than they can combine existence with non-existence'.

- Benedict de Spinoza. Political Treatise. 1677.




Thursday, January 29, 2015

Philosophical Grammar 139


139. I do not scruple to invent causal connections in the mechanism of language.

To invent a keyboard might mean to invent something that had the desired effect; or else to devise new forms which were similar to the old ones in various ways.

“It is always for living beings that signs exist.”



‘inventing causal connections in the mechanism of language’?

this ‘mechanism of language’ is itself an invention – or should I say a proposal –

and yes this is what we do in the business of explaining – and accounting for –

we invent – we propose – to suit our purposes – whatever they may be

and the logical reality is that any ‘invention’ – any proposal – any proposition –

be it in the form of language – or in some other form – as in the example above – a keyboard –

is open to question – to doubt – is uncertain

it is really not as if there are old forms and new forms – just different forms –

different forms for different purposes

It is always for living beings that signs exist’?

we make signs  – we propose

we make proposals – propositions – basic and complex –

in order to describe –

that which in the absence of our proposals –

is unknown



© greg t. charlton. 2015.