'For the person or persons that hold dominion, can no more combine with the keeping up of majesty the running with harlots drunk or naked about the streets, or the performances of a stage player, or the open violation or contempt of laws passed by themselves than they can combine existence with non-existence'.

- Benedict de Spinoza. Political Treatise. 1677.




Thursday, December 11, 2014

Philosophical Grammar 78


78. Sounding like a sentence. We don’t call everything ‘that sounds like a sentence’ a sentence. – If we disregard sounding like a sentence do we still have a general concept of proposition?

The example of a language in which the order of the words in a sentence is the reverse of the present one.



a proposition is a proposal – that which is proposed

that which is put forward

whether that be a sentence – a piece of music – a work of art – or whatever

are we to say for instance that a grunt is a proposal?

probably not – but there might well be a context – in which a grunt raises questions – raises doubts

‘The example of a language in which the order of the words in a sentence is the reverse of the present one.’?

well as put here – it is a proposal – isn’t it?



© greg t. charlton. 2014.