'For the person or persons that hold dominion, can no more combine with the keeping up of majesty the running with harlots drunk or naked about the streets, or the performances of a stage player, or the open violation or contempt of laws passed by themselves than they can combine existence with non-existence'.

- Benedict de Spinoza. Political Treatise. 1677.




Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Philosophical Grammar 5


5. “ I understand this gesture” – it says something.

In a sentence a word can be felt as belonging first with one word and then with another.

A ‘proposition’ may be what is conceived in different ways or the way of conceiving itself.

A sentence from the middle of a story I have not read.

The concept of understanding is a fluid one.



“ I understand this gesture” – it says something –

here the gesture is a proposed – takes the form of a proposal – a proposition –

open to question – open to doubt

the claim to understand – is to state that an interpretation has been and settled on

‘In a sentence a word can be felt as belonging first with one word and then with another.’

yes in any arrangement of words there is uncertainty

‘A ‘proposition’ may be what is conceived in different ways or the way of conceiving itself.’

yes – a proposition can be conceived in any number of ways

‘A sentence from the middle of a story I have not read.’ –

is open to question – open to interpretation

‘The concept of understanding is a fluid one.’

understanding is propositional engagement – and that can take any number of forms



© greg t. charlton. 2014.