Monday, December 22, 2014

Philosophical Grammar 95


95. Intention and intentionality. –

“The thought that p is the case doesn’t presuppose that it is the case: yet I can’t think that something is red if the colour red does not exist.” Here we mean the existence of a red sample as part of our language.



‘The thought that p is the case doesn’t presuppose that it is the case’?

the thought that p is the proposal that p –

the proposal that p is the case – obviously doesn’t presuppose that it is the case

a proposition is a proposal – open to question – open to doubt – uncertain

‘that p’ – is uncertain

‘yet I can’t think that something is red if the colour red does not exist’?

what exists is what is proposed –

if the color red is proposed – the colour red exists

and there will be any number of proposals – propositions –

to account for – to explain – the colour red

in the absence of any description – what exists is the unknown

our world is propositional

‘Here we mean the existence of a red sample as part of our language’ ?

yes – we can propose a ‘red sample’ –

and if we do – the proposal – the proposition – is ‘part of our language’

and then the question – what does the proposal – the proposition amount to?

in response to this we can have any number of proposals

and any proposal – any proposition –

is open to question – open to doubt –

is uncertain



© greg t. charlton. 2014.