Wednesday, December 17, 2014

Philosophical Grammar 90


90. How can I expect the event, when it isn’t there at all? – I can imagine a stag that is not there, in this meadow, but not kill one that is not there. – It is not the expected thing that is the fulfillment, but rather its coming about. It is difficult for us to shake off this comparison: a man makes his appearance – an event makes its appearance.



‘How can I expect the event, when it isn’t there at all?’

what is there – in the absence of any proposal – is the unknown

propositions – proposals – make known

my expectation – is just another proposal – another proposition –

open to question – open to doubt – uncertain

‘It is not the expected thing that is the fulfillment, but rather its coming about’?

there is –logically speaking no fulfilment –

if you mean by fulfilment – the absence of doubt

‘It is difficult for us to shake off this comparison: a man makes his appearance – an event makes its appearance.’?

if are to speak correctly of men and events – we are speaking of proposals –
propositions



© greg t. charlton. 2014.