Saturday, December 27, 2014

Philosophical Grammar 105


105. “This queer thing, thought.” – It strikes us as queer when we say that it connects objects in the mind. – We are all ready to pass from it to reality. – How was it possible for thought to deal with the very person himself? Here I am being astonished by my own linguistic expression and momentarily misunderstanding it.



strange as it may sound – ‘thought’ is a proposal – ‘object’ – a proposal – ‘mind’ – a proposal

what we have here is the ‘interconnectedness’ of proposals – proposal in relation to proposals

it is not that we pass from ‘it’ – thought or mind – to reality –

we pass from proposal to proposal

granted these proposals and their interconnectedness is entrenched –  so entrenched that in common and indeed specialized parlance  – they have been – they are reified –

perhaps that is just the mark of success – as in useful propositional action

be that as it may – what we deal with is proposals – propositions – open to question – open to doubt - uncertain

‘How was it possible for thought to deal with the very person himself?’ –

what we have here is propositions dealing with propositions

‘Here I am being astonished by my own linguistic expression and momentarily misunderstanding it.’

there will be no misunderstanding here –

any ‘linguistic expression’ – is open to question – to doubt – is uncertain –

different understandings – conflicting understandings – yes

any understanding – any proposal –

is uncertain



© greg t. charlton. 2014.