Wednesday, May 19, 2010

on certainty 468


4.4
468. Someone says irreverently “that’s a tree”. He might say this sentence because he remembers hearing it in a similar situation; or he was suddenly struck by the tree’s beauty and the sentence was an exclamation; or he was pronouncing the sentence to himself as a grammatical example; etc., etc. And now I ask him “How did you mean that?’ and he replies ”It was a piece of information directed at you”. Shouldn’t I be at liberty to assume he doesn’t know what he is saying, if he is insane enough to want to give me this information?



you can assume

whatever you like –

bear in mind though –

your assumption –

is uncertain –

is open to question –

open to doubt


© greg t. charlton. 2010.