Monday, May 17, 2010

on certainty 464


3.4.51
464. My difficulty can also be shewn like this: I am sitting talking to a friend. Suddenly I say “I knew all along that you were so-and-so.” Is that really a superfluous, though true, remark?

I feel as if these words were like “Good morning” said to someone in the middle of a conversation.



whether the remark is superfluous or not –

really depends on the understandings of those in the conversation –

and the matter is never fully determined

i.e. what immediately strikes one as superfluous –

might on review be seen in a different light


© greg t. charlton. 2010.