Friday, July 10, 2009

on certainty 60


60. It is wrong to say that the ‘hypothesis’ that this is a bit of paper would be confirmed or disconfirmed by later experience, and that, in “I know that this is a bit of paper,” the “I know” either relates to such an hypothesis or to a logical determination.



this ‘hypothesis’ – will not be confirmed or disconfirmed –

it will be used or it won’t be used –

correct – the ‘I know’ – does not relate to the hypothesis –

and it is logically irrelevant to it

it’s only possible value is rhetorical


© greg t. charlton. 2009.